Online Journalism - Spring 2008: 4/20/08

Citizen Journalism: Response

I am writing a profile on the founder and editor of RethinkCollegePark.net for another class, so I've been spending a lot of time on the site in the past week. I was happy to see it on the first list of citizen journalism sites, because it definitely fits that criteria. I've been getting an idea of what moved Rob and his partner, David Daddio, to start the site and what has caused it to keep growing and gaining traction as a source for news and information in the community.

What impresses me the most is the focus on news and information on the site, and from what I've read so far, it's quite balanced. Whereas the editors are obviously very involved with community issues, such as smart development to make College Park a better place to live, work and go to school and the Purple Line transit system, they've taken care to reach out and get voices represented from the community. This includes students, city politicians and University officials. The site is not just them blowing their individual or collective horns about what they think is best for the city. It really is a collective effort.

I also like that they give an opportunity for readers to contribute if they're interested in doing so, beyond comments. They also offer a good balance of media, including video, illustrations and photos in addition to text. It's cleanly designed and easy-to-read.

I've also spent some time on the Silver Spring sites, Silver Spring Singular, and the Silver Spring Penguin this evening. They are quite different approaches to covering the same city, but they represent what I like about the different styles of community/citizen journalism. Silver Spring Singular is - as the title indicates - a single person's view on life in Silver Spring. There are lots of reviews of local establishments and opinions offered on hot topics in the area, such as the retail explosion (now seeing its first closures since the economic downturn), dining options and the controversy over the long-awaited music venue on Colesville Road. For a fairly informal blog, "Sligo" is pretty dedicated. Agree with him or not, it's his view and he does take the time to make contacts with local figures to flesh out his posts. Not bad for a free Blogspot site.

The Silver Spring Penguin, conversely, functions more as an online community newspaper. It has a dedicated masthead and layout, is regularly updated in consistent sections, and is edited by two people instead of blogged by one. I have a soft spot for alternative news. I believe it's needed now more than ever and has a logical place on the Web. It's great to see it in this "hyperlocal" format. Unlike RethinkCollegePark which is focused on developmental issues, the Penguin touches on all aspects of life in Silver Spring.

I consume all of the media I read, watch and here with my filters on. Writing in Poynter Online, Rick Edmonds complained that Wikinews missed a story or two and that made them less than formidable news sites. Like Wikinews, all of the sources I've named above are run as part-time and in most cases volunteer enterprises. It seems ridiculous to complain about the misses and the omissions when it's a work in progress run as an alternative to mainstream media. I point this out to say that whereas I wouldn't expect any of the above sites to provide me with comprehensive news enough to make them all I'd need, they are not in any way a negative complement to my daily media diet.

April 21: on citizen journalism

In next week's class, April 28, we're going to spend some time talking a little more about writing, blogs and the idea of "citizen journalism." During tonight's class, I'd like you to do two things.

First, read over these two articles about the concept:
From PBS: http://www.pbs.org/mediashift/2006/09/digging_deeperyour_guide_to_ci.html
From Poynter: http://www.poynter.org/content/content_view.asp?id=91391

Second, spend some time exploring different citizen journalism sites. A citizen journalist site and a blog are not necessarily the same thing, though they can be. After you've looked through, read and scanned some different sites, find one that moves you in a particular way -- either strongly for, or strongly against, what the site is doing. Post your response and ideas by the end of class. Next week, we'll discuss. Your response should be between 250-300 words (about the length of Jenn's previous project critique)

Some pages that offer links to different citizen journalism sites:
http://www.kcnn.org/citmedia_sites/
http://www.cyberjournalist.net/news/002226.php

Dreamweaver practice URLS

Online Journalism - Spring 2008

4.21.2008

Citizen Journalism: Response

April 21: on citizen journalism

Dreamweaver practice URLS

Class Syllabus

HTML links

Dreamweaver Links

Blog Archive

Contributors

Visit These Sites!